# A Skills-Based Approach — The First Days and Weeks

> The myth of "natural, so it must be easy" There is this persistent, slightly annoying myth floating around that because breastfeeding is "natural," it should...

### [Course outline](https://breastisbreast.com/course)

Start Here

- [Welcome](https://breastisbreast.com/course/course-orientation/welcome)
- [Why Evidence-Based?](https://breastisbreast.com/course/course-orientation/why-evidence-based)
- [How to Read the Evidence](https://breastisbreast.com/course/course-orientation/how-to-read-the-evidence)

How Milk Works

- [The physiology of milk production](https://breastisbreast.com/course/building-supply/milk-production)
- [Milk Ejection (A.K.A. "the let down")](https://breastisbreast.com/course/building-supply/milk-ejection)
- [Supply and Demand: How Your Body Calibrates](https://breastisbreast.com/course/building-supply/supply-and-demand)

The First Days and Weeks

- [A Skills-Based Approach](https://breastisbreast.com/course/the-first-days/skills-based-approach)
- [Colostrum](https://breastisbreast.com/course/the-first-days/colostrum)
- [The First Latch](https://breastisbreast.com/course/the-first-days/the-first-latch)
- [Is Baby Getting Enough?](https://breastisbreast.com/course/the-first-days/is-baby-getting-enough)
- [Cluster Feeding and Normal Newborn Behavior](https://breastisbreast.com/course/the-first-days/normal-newborn-behavior)
- [When to Get Help](https://breastisbreast.com/course/the-first-days/when-to-get-help)

Establishing & Regulating Supply

- [The First Six Weeks](https://breastisbreast.com/course/regulating-supply/the-first-six-weeks)
- [Pumping Basics](https://breastisbreast.com/course/regulating-supply/pumping-basics)
- [Exclusive Pumping](https://breastisbreast.com/course/regulating-supply/exclusive-pumping)
- [Low Supply: Real vs. Perceived](https://breastisbreast.com/course/regulating-supply/low-supply)
- [Increasing Supply: What Works, What Doesn't](https://breastisbreast.com/course/regulating-supply/increasing-supply)
- [Oversupply and Engorgement](https://breastisbreast.com/course/regulating-supply/oversupply-and-engorgement)

Common Challenges

- [Pain and Latch Trouble](https://breastisbreast.com/course/common-challenges/pain-and-latch-trouble)
- [Clogged Ducts and Mastitis](https://breastisbreast.com/course/common-challenges/clogged-ducts-and-mastitis)
- [Tongue Ties: What the Evidence Says](https://breastisbreast.com/course/common-challenges/tongue-ties)
- [Nursing Strikes, Teething, and Biting](https://breastisbreast.com/course/common-challenges/nursing-strikes-and-biting)
- [D-MER and Nursing Aversion](https://breastisbreast.com/course/common-challenges/dmer-and-nursing-aversion)

Bottles, Formula, and Milk Storage

- [Introducing a Bottle](https://breastisbreast.com/course/bottles-and-formula/introducing-a-bottle)
- [Combo Feeding Without Guilt](https://breastisbreast.com/course/bottles-and-formula/combo-feeding)
- [Safe Formula Preparation](https://breastisbreast.com/course/bottles-and-formula/safe-formula-preparation)
- [Milk Storage](https://breastisbreast.com/course/bottles-and-formula/milk-storage)

Taking Care of You

- [Medications and Milk](https://breastisbreast.com/course/taking-care-of-you/medications-and-milk)
- [Diet, Alcohol, and Caffeine](https://breastisbreast.com/course/taking-care-of-you/diet-alcohol-and-caffeine)
- [Sleep and Night Feeds](https://breastisbreast.com/course/taking-care-of-you/sleep-and-night-feeds)
- [Your Mind: Postpartum Mental Health](https://breastisbreast.com/course/taking-care-of-you/postpartum-mental-health)
- [The Partner's Role](https://breastisbreast.com/course/taking-care-of-you/the-partners-role)
- [The Boob Flu (Mastitis)](https://breastisbreast.com/course/taking-care-of-you/the-boob-flu)

Special Situations

- [Premature and NICU Babies](https://breastisbreast.com/course/special-situations/premature-and-nicu-babies)
- [Nursing When You're Sick](https://breastisbreast.com/course/special-situations/nursing-when-youre-sick)
- [Relactation and Induced Lactation](https://breastisbreast.com/course/special-situations/relactation-and-induced-lactation)

The Long Game

- [Returning to Work](https://breastisbreast.com/course/the-long-game/returning-to-work)
- [Starting Solids](https://breastisbreast.com/course/the-long-game/starting-solids)
- [Weaning on Your Terms](https://breastisbreast.com/course/the-long-game/weaning-on-your-terms)

[Course](https://breastisbreast.com/course)/The First Days and Weeks/A Skills-Based Approach
# A Skills-Based Approach

## The myth of "natural, so it must be easy"

There is this persistent, slightly annoying myth floating around that because breastfeeding is "natural," it should also be "easy." We tend to imagine it should be like a Disney movie where the birds chirp, the sun shines, and your baby just instinctively executes a perfect latch while you sip tea.

If that's your experience? Amazing! Send us some of that magic. But for a whole lot of us, the reality is a bit more... challenging (or crazy-making? Can I say that?).

The research is firmly on your side here. In a study that followed 532 first-time mothers, 92% reported at least one breastfeeding concern by day 3 — most often trouble with the baby feeding at the breast, pain, and worries about milk quantity [(Wagner et al., 2013)](https://breastisbreast.com/course/the-first-days/skills-based-approach#ref-wagner-2013). If breastfeeding were pure instinct, that number would not exist.

## You are not failing; you are practicing

Let go of how you think it should be, and accept it for what it is: an activity that requires skill on the part of both mama and baby. Some pairs click instantly, but for many, it takes practice, adjustments, and maybe a few "let's try that again" moments.

If you're struggling to find your groove, please hear this: You are not failing; you are practicing. You are learning your baby's cues, and your baby is learning how to navigate the world.

And like any skill, this one responds to coaching. A large Cochrane review — 73 studies, roughly 75,000 mother-baby pairs — found that ongoing, skilled breastfeeding support helps women breastfeed longer [(McFadden et al., 2017)](https://breastisbreast.com/course/the-first-days/skills-based-approach#ref-mcfadden-2017). If things keep feeling hard, that's not a character flaw; it's a cue to bring in a lactation consultant (IBCLC) or your provider, ideally sooner rather than later.

## Enter: the training wheels

If you find yourself needing a little extra support — whether that's using donor milk, incorporating formula, or pumping into a bottle so someone else can take a shift — guess what? That is your toolkit. When supplementation is genuinely needed, there are well-established ways to do it that protect breastfeeding rather than derail it; the [Academy of Breastfeeding Medicine](https://www.bfmed.org/protocols) has a whole clinical protocol on exactly this [(Kellams et al., 2017)](https://breastisbreast.com/course/the-first-days/skills-based-approach#ref-kellams-2017).

Think of these options like training wheels on a bicycle. They aren't there because you can't ride; they're there to keep everyone upright and moving forward while you build the muscle memory and confidence to go two-wheeled. Whether you use those training wheels for a week, a month, or the whole ride, the goal is exactly the same: a fed baby and a sane, empowered parent.

## About that "nipple confusion" panic

Give yourself some grace. You're learning a brand-new craft on zero sleep. Tell all those people screaming "breast is best! Don't you dare use a bottle, they'll get nipple confusion!!" to suck it.

For what it's worth, the science backs you up: a review of the research on nipple confusion found the evidence far weaker than the shouting suggests — no study has established that bottles _cause_ breast refusal (versus just showing up alongside other feeding challenges), and the evidence against pacifiers is thinner still [(Zimmerman & Thompson, 2015)](https://breastisbreast.com/course/the-first-days/skills-based-approach#ref-zimmerman-2015).

## The only three goals

There really are only three goals:

1. **Keep baby fed.**
2. **Protect your supply.** Milk production runs on milk removal — the more milk leaves the breast, by baby or by pump, the more your body makes [(Lawrence & Lawrence, 2021)](https://breastisbreast.com/course/the-first-days/skills-based-approach#ref-lawrence-2021). So however you feed, keeping milk moving keeps your options open.
3. **Stay sane.** This one isn't fluff: maternal mental health and feeding are deeply intertwined, and struggling with one tends to strain the other [(Dennis & McQueen, 2009)](https://breastisbreast.com/course/the-first-days/skills-based-approach#ref-dennis-2009). If the "sane" part is slipping, that's worth a conversation with your provider, full stop.

How you reach each of those goals is up to you. There is no single perfect plan, and you can cobble together approaches and modify as you go along. You've got this, and we've got you.

## The bottom line

- Breastfeeding is natural _and_ it's a learned skill — for both of you. Early struggles are the norm, not a red flag: 92% of first-time mothers report at least one concern by day 3 [(Wagner et al., 2013)](https://breastisbreast.com/course/the-first-days/skills-based-approach#ref-wagner-2013).
- Donor milk, formula, and pumped bottles are tools, not failures — training wheels that keep everyone fed while you build the skill.
- The evidence behind "nipple confusion" is much shakier than the warnings imply [(Zimmerman & Thompson, 2015)](https://breastisbreast.com/course/the-first-days/skills-based-approach#ref-zimmerman-2015).
- Three goals, in order: keep baby fed, protect your supply, stay sane. Any plan that hits all three is a good plan.
- Skilled support works — if it keeps feeling hard, loop in an IBCLC or your provider early.

## References

- Wagner et al., 2013 · Pediatrics · [Breastfeeding Concerns at 3 and 7 Days Postpartum and Feeding Status at 2 Months](https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/24062375/)
- McFadden et al., 2017 · Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews · [Support for Healthy Breastfeeding Mothers with Healthy Term Babies](https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/28244064/)
- Kellams et al., 2017 · Breastfeeding Medicine · [ABM Clinical Protocol #3: Supplementary Feedings in the Healthy Term Breastfed Neonate, Revised 2017](https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/28294631/)
- Zimmerman & Thompson, 2015 · Journal of Perinatology · [Clarifying Nipple Confusion](https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/26181720/)
- Dennis & McQueen, 2009 · Pediatrics · [The Relationship Between Infant-Feeding Outcomes and Postpartum Depression: A Qualitative Systematic Review](https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/19336362/)
- Lawrence & Lawrence, 2021 · Elsevier · [Breastfeeding: A Guide for the Medical Profession (9th ed.)](https://www.us.elsevierhealth.com/breastfeeding-9780323680134.html)

[Previous Supply and Demand: How Your Body Calibrates](https://breastisbreast.com/course/building-supply/supply-and-demand)

[Next Colostrum](https://breastisbreast.com/course/the-first-days/colostrum)

Course outline

Start Here

- [Welcome](https://breastisbreast.com/course/course-orientation/welcome)
- [Why Evidence-Based?](https://breastisbreast.com/course/course-orientation/why-evidence-based)
- [How to Read the Evidence](https://breastisbreast.com/course/course-orientation/how-to-read-the-evidence)

How Milk Works

- [The physiology of milk production](https://breastisbreast.com/course/building-supply/milk-production)
- [Milk Ejection (A.K.A. "the let down")](https://breastisbreast.com/course/building-supply/milk-ejection)
- [Supply and Demand: How Your Body Calibrates](https://breastisbreast.com/course/building-supply/supply-and-demand)

The First Days and Weeks

- [A Skills-Based Approach](https://breastisbreast.com/course/the-first-days/skills-based-approach)
- [Colostrum](https://breastisbreast.com/course/the-first-days/colostrum)
- [The First Latch](https://breastisbreast.com/course/the-first-days/the-first-latch)
- [Is Baby Getting Enough?](https://breastisbreast.com/course/the-first-days/is-baby-getting-enough)
- [Cluster Feeding and Normal Newborn Behavior](https://breastisbreast.com/course/the-first-days/normal-newborn-behavior)
- [When to Get Help](https://breastisbreast.com/course/the-first-days/when-to-get-help)

Establishing & Regulating Supply

- [The First Six Weeks](https://breastisbreast.com/course/regulating-supply/the-first-six-weeks)
- [Pumping Basics](https://breastisbreast.com/course/regulating-supply/pumping-basics)
- [Exclusive Pumping](https://breastisbreast.com/course/regulating-supply/exclusive-pumping)
- [Low Supply: Real vs. Perceived](https://breastisbreast.com/course/regulating-supply/low-supply)
- [Increasing Supply: What Works, What Doesn't](https://breastisbreast.com/course/regulating-supply/increasing-supply)
- [Oversupply and Engorgement](https://breastisbreast.com/course/regulating-supply/oversupply-and-engorgement)

Common Challenges

- [Pain and Latch Trouble](https://breastisbreast.com/course/common-challenges/pain-and-latch-trouble)
- [Clogged Ducts and Mastitis](https://breastisbreast.com/course/common-challenges/clogged-ducts-and-mastitis)
- [Tongue Ties: What the Evidence Says](https://breastisbreast.com/course/common-challenges/tongue-ties)
- [Nursing Strikes, Teething, and Biting](https://breastisbreast.com/course/common-challenges/nursing-strikes-and-biting)
- [D-MER and Nursing Aversion](https://breastisbreast.com/course/common-challenges/dmer-and-nursing-aversion)

Bottles, Formula, and Milk Storage

- [Introducing a Bottle](https://breastisbreast.com/course/bottles-and-formula/introducing-a-bottle)
- [Combo Feeding Without Guilt](https://breastisbreast.com/course/bottles-and-formula/combo-feeding)
- [Safe Formula Preparation](https://breastisbreast.com/course/bottles-and-formula/safe-formula-preparation)
- [Milk Storage](https://breastisbreast.com/course/bottles-and-formula/milk-storage)

Taking Care of You

- [Medications and Milk](https://breastisbreast.com/course/taking-care-of-you/medications-and-milk)
- [Diet, Alcohol, and Caffeine](https://breastisbreast.com/course/taking-care-of-you/diet-alcohol-and-caffeine)
- [Sleep and Night Feeds](https://breastisbreast.com/course/taking-care-of-you/sleep-and-night-feeds)
- [Your Mind: Postpartum Mental Health](https://breastisbreast.com/course/taking-care-of-you/postpartum-mental-health)
- [The Partner's Role](https://breastisbreast.com/course/taking-care-of-you/the-partners-role)
- [The Boob Flu (Mastitis)](https://breastisbreast.com/course/taking-care-of-you/the-boob-flu)

Special Situations

- [Premature and NICU Babies](https://breastisbreast.com/course/special-situations/premature-and-nicu-babies)
- [Nursing When You're Sick](https://breastisbreast.com/course/special-situations/nursing-when-youre-sick)
- [Relactation and Induced Lactation](https://breastisbreast.com/course/special-situations/relactation-and-induced-lactation)

The Long Game

- [Returning to Work](https://breastisbreast.com/course/the-long-game/returning-to-work)
- [Starting Solids](https://breastisbreast.com/course/the-long-game/starting-solids)
- [Weaning on Your Terms](https://breastisbreast.com/course/the-long-game/weaning-on-your-terms)
