# Tongue Ties: What the Evidence Says — Common Challenges

> If you've mentioned painful nursing or a fussy feeder anywhere on the internet lately, someone has probably told you your baby has a tongue tie. Maybe a lip...

### [Course outline](https://breastisbreast.com/course)

Start Here

- [Welcome](https://breastisbreast.com/course/course-orientation/welcome)
- [Why Evidence-Based?](https://breastisbreast.com/course/course-orientation/why-evidence-based)
- [How to Read the Evidence](https://breastisbreast.com/course/course-orientation/how-to-read-the-evidence)

How Milk Works

- [The physiology of milk production](https://breastisbreast.com/course/building-supply/milk-production)
- [Milk Ejection (A.K.A. "the let down")](https://breastisbreast.com/course/building-supply/milk-ejection)
- [Supply and Demand: How Your Body Calibrates](https://breastisbreast.com/course/building-supply/supply-and-demand)

The First Days and Weeks

- [A Skills-Based Approach](https://breastisbreast.com/course/the-first-days/skills-based-approach)
- [Colostrum](https://breastisbreast.com/course/the-first-days/colostrum)
- [The First Latch](https://breastisbreast.com/course/the-first-days/the-first-latch)
- [Is Baby Getting Enough?](https://breastisbreast.com/course/the-first-days/is-baby-getting-enough)
- [Cluster Feeding and Normal Newborn Behavior](https://breastisbreast.com/course/the-first-days/normal-newborn-behavior)
- [When to Get Help](https://breastisbreast.com/course/the-first-days/when-to-get-help)

Establishing & Regulating Supply

- [The First Six Weeks](https://breastisbreast.com/course/regulating-supply/the-first-six-weeks)
- [Pumping Basics](https://breastisbreast.com/course/regulating-supply/pumping-basics)
- [Exclusive Pumping](https://breastisbreast.com/course/regulating-supply/exclusive-pumping)
- [Low Supply: Real vs. Perceived](https://breastisbreast.com/course/regulating-supply/low-supply)
- [Increasing Supply: What Works, What Doesn't](https://breastisbreast.com/course/regulating-supply/increasing-supply)
- [Oversupply and Engorgement](https://breastisbreast.com/course/regulating-supply/oversupply-and-engorgement)

Common Challenges

- [Pain and Latch Trouble](https://breastisbreast.com/course/common-challenges/pain-and-latch-trouble)
- [Clogged Ducts and Mastitis](https://breastisbreast.com/course/common-challenges/clogged-ducts-and-mastitis)
- [Tongue Ties: What the Evidence Says](https://breastisbreast.com/course/common-challenges/tongue-ties)
- [Nursing Strikes, Teething, and Biting](https://breastisbreast.com/course/common-challenges/nursing-strikes-and-biting)
- [D-MER and Nursing Aversion](https://breastisbreast.com/course/common-challenges/dmer-and-nursing-aversion)

Bottles, Formula, and Milk Storage

- [Introducing a Bottle](https://breastisbreast.com/course/bottles-and-formula/introducing-a-bottle)
- [Combo Feeding Without Guilt](https://breastisbreast.com/course/bottles-and-formula/combo-feeding)
- [Safe Formula Preparation](https://breastisbreast.com/course/bottles-and-formula/safe-formula-preparation)
- [Milk Storage](https://breastisbreast.com/course/bottles-and-formula/milk-storage)

Taking Care of You

- [Medications and Milk](https://breastisbreast.com/course/taking-care-of-you/medications-and-milk)
- [Diet, Alcohol, and Caffeine](https://breastisbreast.com/course/taking-care-of-you/diet-alcohol-and-caffeine)
- [Sleep and Night Feeds](https://breastisbreast.com/course/taking-care-of-you/sleep-and-night-feeds)
- [Your Mind: Postpartum Mental Health](https://breastisbreast.com/course/taking-care-of-you/postpartum-mental-health)
- [The Partner's Role](https://breastisbreast.com/course/taking-care-of-you/the-partners-role)
- [The Boob Flu (Mastitis)](https://breastisbreast.com/course/taking-care-of-you/the-boob-flu)

Special Situations

- [Premature and NICU Babies](https://breastisbreast.com/course/special-situations/premature-and-nicu-babies)
- [Nursing When You're Sick](https://breastisbreast.com/course/special-situations/nursing-when-youre-sick)
- [Relactation and Induced Lactation](https://breastisbreast.com/course/special-situations/relactation-and-induced-lactation)

The Long Game

- [Returning to Work](https://breastisbreast.com/course/the-long-game/returning-to-work)
- [Starting Solids](https://breastisbreast.com/course/the-long-game/starting-solids)
- [Weaning on Your Terms](https://breastisbreast.com/course/the-long-game/weaning-on-your-terms)

[Course](https://breastisbreast.com/course)/Common Challenges/Tongue Ties: What the Evidence Says
# Tongue Ties: What the Evidence Says

If you've mentioned painful nursing or a fussy feeder anywhere on the internet lately, someone has probably told you your baby has a tongue tie. Maybe a lip tie too. Possibly cheek ties, which — yes, that's now a thing people diagnose from photos.

Tongue tie (the medical term is ankyloglossia) is real: some babies are born with a lingual frenulum — the little band of tissue under the tongue — that genuinely restricts tongue movement and makes feeding harder. But somewhere between "this exists" and "this explains everything," the conversation went off the rails. This lesson is about finding your footing in it.

## Diagnoses have risen — a lot

In the US, inpatient diagnoses of ankyloglossia went from about 3,900 in 1997 to nearly 33,000 in 2012 — roughly an eightfold increase in fifteen years [(Walsh et al., 2017)](https://breastisbreast.com/course/common-challenges/tongue-ties#ref-walsh-2017). Frenotomies (the procedure that releases the frenulum) rose right along with it.

Did babies' mouths change? No. What changed is how often we look for ties, how broadly we define them, and how quickly we treat them. Some of that rise is good news — babies with genuine restriction getting help that used to be missed. And some of it is a diagnosis expanding to cover problems it doesn't actually explain. Both things are true at once, which is exactly why this topic feels so confusing from the inside.

## Function matters more than appearance

Here's the single most useful idea in this lesson: **what a frenulum looks like matters much less than what the tongue can do.**

Plenty of babies have a visible, even prominent frenulum and feed beautifully. The expert consensus from pediatric ENTs is blunt about this: most infants with ankyloglossia don't have feeding problems, and a tight-looking frenulum in a baby who is feeding well doesn't need treatment [(Messner et al., 2020)](https://breastisbreast.com/course/common-challenges/tongue-ties#ref-messner-2020). The American Academy of Pediatrics takes the same line — a tie only counts as "symptomatic" when it causes feeding problems that _persist after skilled lactation support_, and evaluating one requires actually watching a feed, not just looking under the tongue [(Thomas et al., 2024)](https://breastisbreast.com/course/common-challenges/tongue-ties#ref-thomas-2024).

So the question is never "does my baby have a frenulum?" (everyone has one). It's: can the tongue lift, extend, and cup to transfer milk — and if not, is the frenulum actually the reason?

## Anterior, posterior, and the controversy

You'll hear ties sorted into two camps:

| Type | What it means | Where the evidence stands |
| --- | --- | --- |
| **Anterior tie** | The frenulum attaches at or near the tongue tip; visible and often obviously restrictive | The classic, well-recognized form. This is what most of the research studies. |
| **Posterior tie** | A tighter or thicker band further back, sometimes described as "hidden" under the mucosa | Genuinely contested. There's no agreed-upon definition or reliable way to diagnose it, and experts disagree about whether many of these diagnoses represent restriction at all [(Messner et al., 2020)](https://breastisbreast.com/course/common-challenges/tongue-ties#ref-messner-2020). |

That doesn't mean every baby diagnosed with a posterior tie is fine — some babies with feeding trouble do have restricted tongues that aren't obvious at a glance. It means a "posterior tie" label, by itself, tells you very little. What tells you something is a functional feeding assessment.

## What the frenotomy evidence actually shows

Frenotomy itself is quick and, in the newborn period, low-risk — a snip (or laser division) of the frenulum, usually taking seconds. The question isn't really "is it dangerous?" It's "does it fix the problem?"

The best summary comes from a Cochrane review of five randomized trials, 302 infants [(O'Shea et al., 2017)](https://breastisbreast.com/course/common-challenges/tongue-ties#ref-oshea-2017):

- **Maternal nipple pain improved in the short term** — a modest but real reduction in pain scores.
- **Infant feeding improvement was inconsistent** — pooled studies found no change on one feeding scale, while a smaller study found improvement on another.
- **No serious adverse effects** were reported in the trials.
- The trials were small, mostly unblinded, and too short to say anything about long-term breastfeeding outcomes.

Translated: for a baby with a genuine tie and real feeding difficulty, frenotomy can help — most clearly with maternal pain, less certainly with anything else. What the evidence does _not_ show is that frenotomy reliably fixes low weight gain, gas, reflux, colic, sleep problems, or future speech issues. Those claims outrun the data.

## Red flags of the overtreatment culture

None of this makes providers who treat ties villains — many are skilled clinicians helping babies who need it. But a cash-pay ecosystem has grown up around ties, and it's worth knowing the patterns that should slow you down:

- **A tie diagnosed without watching a feed.** If nobody assessed how your baby actually nurses or takes a bottle, the evaluation isn't done yet.
- **One explanation for every symptom.** Pain, gas, reflux, poor sleep, fussiness, "clicking" — if a single diagnosis explains all of it, be curious about what else was ruled out.
- **Bundled procedures.** Tongue tie plus lip tie plus cheek ties, released in one visit, often by laser, often for a four-figure out-of-pocket fee. Lip and cheek tie releases have far less evidence behind them than lingual frenotomy [(Thomas et al., 2024)](https://breastisbreast.com/course/common-challenges/tongue-ties#ref-thomas-2024).
- **Urgency.**"The window is closing" is a sales technique, not a clinical fact. A tie that truly needs release can be released next week too.
- **Weeks of mandatory "bodywork" or stretching regimens** sold as essential to the outcome — these are not supported by the clinical evidence.

Here's the study that makes the point best: at one hospital program, babies referred _specifically for frenotomy_ first got a thorough feeding evaluation from a speech-language pathologist. Nearly 63% ended up not needing the procedure — their feeding problems had other fixable causes [(Caloway et al., 2019)](https://breastisbreast.com/course/common-challenges/tongue-ties#ref-caloway-2019). Positioning, latch mechanics, flow issues, [oversupply](https://breastisbreast.com/course/regulating-supply/oversupply-and-engorgement), and plain old newborn learning curves can all masquerade as a tie.

## A sane pathway

If feeding hurts or your baby seems to struggle, here's an order of operations the evidence supports:

1. **Start with a feeding assessment by an IBCLC** (or a feeding-trained SLP). Not because ties aren't real, but because most feeding problems aren't ties — and the fixable-without-a-scalpel causes should be found first. Our lesson on [pain and latch trouble](https://breastisbreast.com/course/common-challenges/pain-and-latch-trouble) covers what that workup looks like.
2. **If a tie still looks likely, get an evaluation from a clinician who examines function** — tongue movement during an actual feed — not just anatomy. Your pediatrician, a pediatric ENT, or a breastfeeding-medicine physician are good options.
3. **Get a second opinion if anything feels rushed** , especially before laser procedures, lip/cheek releases, or anything with a big price tag.
4. **Know that declining or waiting is a legitimate choice.** If feeding is going well enough and improving, watchful waiting is an evidence-backed option, not negligence. You can revisit the decision at any point.
5. **And if you do choose frenotomy, that's legitimate too.** For the right baby, it's a quick, low-risk procedure with a real chance of helping — particularly with pain.

However this shakes out, every feeding path stays open: nursing, pumping, combo-feeding, and formula are all first-class ways to feed a baby, tie or no tie.

**When to seek care promptly:** slow or no weight gain, fewer wet diapers than expected, or signs of dehydration are pediatrician-today issues regardless of what's causing them — see [is baby getting enough](https://breastisbreast.com/course/the-first-days/is-baby-getting-enough). Severe, persistent nipple pain or damage deserves an IBCLC visit this week, not a grit-your-teeth month.

## The bottom line

- Tongue ties are real, but diagnoses have risen roughly eightfold — the label is now applied far more broadly than the evidence supports [(Walsh et al., 2017)](https://breastisbreast.com/course/common-challenges/tongue-ties#ref-walsh-2017).
- Function beats appearance: a tie only matters if it actually restricts tongue movement and disrupts feeding after good lactation support [(Thomas et al., 2024)](https://breastisbreast.com/course/common-challenges/tongue-ties#ref-thomas-2024).
- The trial evidence shows frenotomy reduces maternal nipple pain short-term in selected cases; benefits beyond that are uncertain [(O'Shea et al., 2017)](https://breastisbreast.com/course/common-challenges/tongue-ties#ref-oshea-2017).
- When babies referred for frenotomy got a real feeding evaluation first, nearly two-thirds didn't need the procedure [(Caloway et al., 2019)](https://breastisbreast.com/course/common-challenges/tongue-ties#ref-caloway-2019).
- A sane path: IBCLC feeding assessment first, function-based evaluation second, second opinions welcome — and both declining and proceeding are legitimate, revisable choices.

_This lesson is educational content, not medical advice. Decisions about evaluating or treating a tongue tie belong with you, your pediatrician, and your feeding team._

## References

- Walsh et al., 2017 · Otolaryngology–Head and Neck Surgery · [Ankyloglossia and Lingual Frenotomy: National Trends in Inpatient Diagnosis and Management in the United States, 1997-2012](https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/28168891/)
- Messner et al., 2020 · Otolaryngology–Head and Neck Surgery · [Clinical Consensus Statement: Ankyloglossia in Children](https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/32283998/)
- Thomas et al., 2024 · Pediatrics · [Identification and Management of Ankyloglossia and Its Effect on Breastfeeding in Infants: Clinical Report](https://publications.aap.org/pediatrics/article/154/2/e2024067605/198022/Identification-and-Management-of-Ankyloglossia-and)
- O'Shea et al., 2017 · Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews · [Frenotomy for Tongue-Tie in Newborn Infants](https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/28284020/)
- Caloway et al., 2019 · JAMA Otolaryngology–Head & Neck Surgery · [Association of Feeding Evaluation With Frenotomy Rates in Infants With Breastfeeding Difficulties](https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/31294774/)

[Previous Clogged Ducts and Mastitis](https://breastisbreast.com/course/common-challenges/clogged-ducts-and-mastitis)

[Next Nursing Strikes, Teething, and Biting](https://breastisbreast.com/course/common-challenges/nursing-strikes-and-biting)

Course outline

Start Here

- [Welcome](https://breastisbreast.com/course/course-orientation/welcome)
- [Why Evidence-Based?](https://breastisbreast.com/course/course-orientation/why-evidence-based)
- [How to Read the Evidence](https://breastisbreast.com/course/course-orientation/how-to-read-the-evidence)

How Milk Works

- [The physiology of milk production](https://breastisbreast.com/course/building-supply/milk-production)
- [Milk Ejection (A.K.A. "the let down")](https://breastisbreast.com/course/building-supply/milk-ejection)
- [Supply and Demand: How Your Body Calibrates](https://breastisbreast.com/course/building-supply/supply-and-demand)

The First Days and Weeks

- [A Skills-Based Approach](https://breastisbreast.com/course/the-first-days/skills-based-approach)
- [Colostrum](https://breastisbreast.com/course/the-first-days/colostrum)
- [The First Latch](https://breastisbreast.com/course/the-first-days/the-first-latch)
- [Is Baby Getting Enough?](https://breastisbreast.com/course/the-first-days/is-baby-getting-enough)
- [Cluster Feeding and Normal Newborn Behavior](https://breastisbreast.com/course/the-first-days/normal-newborn-behavior)
- [When to Get Help](https://breastisbreast.com/course/the-first-days/when-to-get-help)

Establishing & Regulating Supply

- [The First Six Weeks](https://breastisbreast.com/course/regulating-supply/the-first-six-weeks)
- [Pumping Basics](https://breastisbreast.com/course/regulating-supply/pumping-basics)
- [Exclusive Pumping](https://breastisbreast.com/course/regulating-supply/exclusive-pumping)
- [Low Supply: Real vs. Perceived](https://breastisbreast.com/course/regulating-supply/low-supply)
- [Increasing Supply: What Works, What Doesn't](https://breastisbreast.com/course/regulating-supply/increasing-supply)
- [Oversupply and Engorgement](https://breastisbreast.com/course/regulating-supply/oversupply-and-engorgement)

Common Challenges

- [Pain and Latch Trouble](https://breastisbreast.com/course/common-challenges/pain-and-latch-trouble)
- [Clogged Ducts and Mastitis](https://breastisbreast.com/course/common-challenges/clogged-ducts-and-mastitis)
- [Tongue Ties: What the Evidence Says](https://breastisbreast.com/course/common-challenges/tongue-ties)
- [Nursing Strikes, Teething, and Biting](https://breastisbreast.com/course/common-challenges/nursing-strikes-and-biting)
- [D-MER and Nursing Aversion](https://breastisbreast.com/course/common-challenges/dmer-and-nursing-aversion)

Bottles, Formula, and Milk Storage

- [Introducing a Bottle](https://breastisbreast.com/course/bottles-and-formula/introducing-a-bottle)
- [Combo Feeding Without Guilt](https://breastisbreast.com/course/bottles-and-formula/combo-feeding)
- [Safe Formula Preparation](https://breastisbreast.com/course/bottles-and-formula/safe-formula-preparation)
- [Milk Storage](https://breastisbreast.com/course/bottles-and-formula/milk-storage)

Taking Care of You

- [Medications and Milk](https://breastisbreast.com/course/taking-care-of-you/medications-and-milk)
- [Diet, Alcohol, and Caffeine](https://breastisbreast.com/course/taking-care-of-you/diet-alcohol-and-caffeine)
- [Sleep and Night Feeds](https://breastisbreast.com/course/taking-care-of-you/sleep-and-night-feeds)
- [Your Mind: Postpartum Mental Health](https://breastisbreast.com/course/taking-care-of-you/postpartum-mental-health)
- [The Partner's Role](https://breastisbreast.com/course/taking-care-of-you/the-partners-role)
- [The Boob Flu (Mastitis)](https://breastisbreast.com/course/taking-care-of-you/the-boob-flu)

Special Situations

- [Premature and NICU Babies](https://breastisbreast.com/course/special-situations/premature-and-nicu-babies)
- [Nursing When You're Sick](https://breastisbreast.com/course/special-situations/nursing-when-youre-sick)
- [Relactation and Induced Lactation](https://breastisbreast.com/course/special-situations/relactation-and-induced-lactation)

The Long Game

- [Returning to Work](https://breastisbreast.com/course/the-long-game/returning-to-work)
- [Starting Solids](https://breastisbreast.com/course/the-long-game/starting-solids)
- [Weaning on Your Terms](https://breastisbreast.com/course/the-long-game/weaning-on-your-terms)
